AD Search Studio

AEO & GEO

GEO vs SEO: What Changes, What Stays the Same, How to Measure

Key takeaways

  • GEO builds on SEO: crawl access, intent research and specific content still decide whether you get retrieved.
  • AI answers judge passages and your brand as a whole, so consistent facts and comparison content matter more.
  • Reviews, listicle placements and genuine Reddit participation shape what AI tools say about you.
  • Measure GEO with a fixed prompt set, AI referral traffic, branded search and self-reported attribution.

GEO (generative engine optimisation) is the work of getting your brand mentioned and cited in AI-generated answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode. SEO is the work of ranking your pages in search results and earning the click. Most of the foundations are shared, but GEO puts far more weight on what other sites say about you, and it needs a different way of measuring success.

I run both across a 12+ brand portfolio at Garage Collective, and the question I hear most from founders is whether they need a separate GEO strategy, a separate agency, or both. Usually neither. They need their SEO programme to cover a few things it has been ignoring. This post sets out what those are, and how to tell whether the work is paying off.

GEO vs SEO at a glance

SEOGEO
What you are trying to winA ranking position and a clickA mention or citation inside the answer
Where it happensSearch results pagesAI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot
What gets judgedThe pageThe passage, and your brand as a whole
Typical queryA short keyword or questionA longer prompt with context, such as "for a 10-person agency in Pune"
Off-site signalsMostly linksLinks, plus unlinked mentions, reviews, roundups and forum threads
Main metricRankings, organic clicks, conversionsShare of mentions across a prompt set, citations, AI referral traffic
How much you controlMost of it, on your own siteLess; a lot of it happens on other people's sites

What stays the same

If your SEO is weak, GEO tactics will not rescue you. AI search tools retrieve web pages before they write an answer, and they tend to retrieve the same kind of pages that rank well.

Crawl access decides whether you exist

Google's AI features draw on Google's own search index. ChatGPT search and Perplexity use their own crawlers, OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot. If robots.txt blocks them, they have less of your site to work with. CDN and firewall bot settings are worth checking too, since they can block AI crawlers without anyone on the marketing side knowing. And do not assume every AI crawler renders JavaScript the way Googlebot does; keep core content in the HTML.

Intent research still drives the plan

Prompts are longer, but the jobs behind them are the ones you already find in keyword research: comparing options, checking prices, fixing a problem, finding an alternative. The funnel-stage keyword planning I use for SaaS maps straight onto prompts. I go into that in B2B SaaS SEO that drives pipeline.

Specific, expert content still wins

Pages written by someone who knows the subject, with real detail, rank better and get quoted more. Thin pages written to hit a keyword do badly in both.

Technical health still matters

Fast pages, clean canonicals, no indexation bloat, sensible internal linking. My technical SEO audit checklist applies unchanged.

What changes

Answers are built from passages

An AI answer is assembled from passages, often from several sites. A page can rank well and still not be quoted if the answer is buried. Formatting for extraction becomes part of the job: answer-first sections, tables for comparisons, statements that make sense out of context. I cover the page-level steps in how to get cited in Google AI Overviews, so I will not repeat them here.

The model forms a view of your brand

Ask "what is the best GST billing software for a small agency" and the answer names brands. Whether yours appears depends partly on how often, and how consistently, the wider web describes you in that context. A brand with a strong website and almost no third-party mentions is easy to leave out.

Comparison is the default format

Many prompts ask the AI to recommend or compare, so answers often come back as a shortlist with a line on each option. That makes comparison, alternatives and "best for" content more valuable than it was. For MoneyGence, a B2B accounting software client, we built comparison, alternatives, use-case and integration pages for this reason: each one gives an AI answer a clear, quotable description of where the product fits.

Your facts need to agree everywhere

If your pricing page says one thing, your G2 profile another and an old roundup a third, the AI answer may repeat any of them. Keep your core facts consistent across your site and every profile: pricing, plans, features, locations, who you serve and who you do not. This matters more now that buyers may read a summary of you instead of your own page.

The click is no longer the whole story

A good AI answer can settle a question without a click. Being named in it still has value, because the buyer may search your brand later or come straight to your site. That changes what you measure, which I cover below.

Free checklist

The AI Citation Checklist

39 checks to get your brand cited in AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini

  • 39 tick-box checks in six sections, in the order we do the work
  • Which AI crawlers to allow in robots.txt, and what each one controls
  • Answer-first formatting rules for passages AI tools can quote

Free. Instant access. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Off-site presence: reviews, listicles and Reddit

This is the part most SEO plans under-resource. In my experience, the sources AI answers lean on for "best X" and "X vs Y" prompts are often review platforms, roundup articles and forum threads rather than brand websites. So the off-page plan has to cover those, alongside links.

Reviews

For B2B SaaS, that means complete, current G2 and Capterra profiles with a steady flow of reviews from real customers. Ask at natural moments: after onboarding, after a support ticket closes well, at renewal. Reply to reviews, including the critical ones, because the replies are public too. For D2C brands, the equivalents are Google Business Profile if you have stores, marketplace listings, and reviews on your own product pages.

Listicles and best-of placements

Run your priority prompts and note which roundup articles get cited. Those are your targets, not every "top 10" post you can find. Then:

  1. Check whether you are already listed and whether the description is accurate.
  2. Contact the author or editor with a specific update: a new feature, corrected pricing, a use case they missed.
  3. Offer something that makes the article better for their readers, such as a trial account so they can test the product properly.
  4. Track which placements start showing up in AI answers over the following months.

Some publishers charge for inclusion. Be honest with yourself about whether a paid spot on a site nobody reads is worth it. The placements that matter are the ones AI answers already cite.

Reddit and forums

In my experience, Reddit threads come up often in AI answers to product questions. The only approach that holds up is genuine participation. Someone who knows the product answers questions in relevant subreddits, says who they work for, and stays helpful even when your product is the wrong fit. Fake accounts and planted recommendations get spotted by moderators and users, and the backlash then becomes part of what gets said about you.

  • G2, Capterra or marketplace profiles complete, with current pricing and screenshots
  • A review request built into the customer journey, not a one-off campaign
  • A list of the roundup articles cited for your priority prompts, with an owner for outreach
  • One or two team members active, under their own names, where your buyers ask questions
  • Core brand facts matching across your site, profiles and directory listings

How to measure GEO

There is no single GEO dashboard I would trust on its own, so I combine four sources.

1. A fixed prompt set

Write 30 to 50 prompts your buyers would actually type, split across early research, comparison and purchase stages. Run them monthly in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Mode, and log:

  • Is your brand mentioned, and where in the list?
  • Is your site cited as a source, and which URL?
  • Which competitors are mentioned, and which sources are cited for them?
  • Is what the answer says about you accurate?

Answers vary between runs, so run each prompt more than once and look at the trend over months, not a single result. Your share of mentions across the whole set, against three or four named competitors, is the closest thing GEO has to a rankings report. Several tools now automate this. They help at scale, but I still read a sample of answers by hand, because accuracy problems only show up when you read them.

2. AI referral traffic in GA4

Set up a custom channel group or an exploration for sessions referred by chatgpt.com, perplexity.ai, gemini.google.com and copilot.microsoft.com. Clicks from AI Overviews and AI Mode are counted as Google organic, so they will not appear separately here. Look at conversion rate as well as volume; in my experience this traffic is small but often arrives further along in the decision.

When AI answers mention you more often, some of that shows up as people searching your brand name. Track branded impressions in Search Console alongside your prompt set results.

4. Ask your customers

Add "ChatGPT or another AI tool" as an option in the "How did you hear about us?" field on sign-up or checkout, and in sales call notes. It is imperfect, but it captures influence no analytics tool can see.

Where to start if you have one quarter

  1. Month 1: write the prompt set and run the baseline. Check that Googlebot, OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot can reach your key pages, and fix anything blocking them.
  2. Month 1: clean up your core facts across your site, review profiles and directories.
  3. Month 2: rework your top comparison, alternatives and category pages for extraction, and fill the gaps the prompt set exposed.
  4. Month 2: start review requests and outreach to the roundups already being cited.
  5. Month 3: begin genuine Reddit and forum participation, then rerun the prompt set and compare it with the baseline.

None of this needs a new department. It needs your content, technical and off-page people working from the same prompt set and the same list of target sources, with one report that shows both search and AI visibility.

Abhishek Dwivedi
Written by Abhishek Dwivedi

Founder of AD Search Studio and a Senior SEO Lead with 7 years in search, running SEO and AEO/GEO programmes across D2C, B2B SaaS and banking brands.

View Abhishek's portfolio

FAQ

Commonquestions.

Still unsure? Ask us directly.

Get in touch

No. AI search tools still retrieve pages from search indexes before they write an answer, so crawlability, relevance and authority still decide whether you can be cited. GEO adds off-site presence and a different way of measuring on top of SEO.

Free AI search audit

See how Googleand AI see you.

Send your site and our founder reviews it personally. You get a clear, prioritised read on what is holding your search growth back.

  • Technical health: crawl, indexation and speed issues that cap growth
  • AI visibility: how ChatGPT, Perplexity and AI Overviews describe your brand
  • Content gaps: the high-intent queries competitors win and you don't
  • The three fixes worth the most revenue, in order

Free, no obligation. Your details are only used to reply to you.

Talk to the founder

Ready to bethe answer?

Tell us what you want to rank for and where growth has stalled. We will tell you straight whether search is the right lever, and what it is worth.

Abhishek DwivediFounder and Lead Strategist, AD Search Studio

Abhishek Dwivedi